Home | News | Regional | Nancy McGeoghean who doesn't remember killing daughter pleads for freedom

Nancy McGeoghean who doesn't remember killing daughter pleads for freedom

By
Font size: Decrease font Enlarge font
  • Nancy McGeoghean, 45, is pleading for her freedom after receiving a life sentence for killing her two-year-old daughter more than 20 years ago
  • McGeoghean woke up on Aug. 15 1988 to find her daughter, Sarah, laying unresponsive in a car seat on the living room floor
  • McGeoghean said she doesn't remember killing Sarah but believes she did, as there is 'no other explanation'
  • McGeoghean is being given a rare chance to persuade state officials to recommend she be eligible for release from prison

By Charlene Adams for MailOnline

Published: 14:18 EST, 5 January 2015 | Updated: 16:17 EST, 5 January 2015

View
comments

A Massachusetts woman imprisoned for more than 20 years after killing her two-year-old daughter is now pleading for her freedom.

On August 15, 1988, Nancy McGeoghean, then 20 years old, allegedly strangled her two-year-old daughter, Sarah, and smothered her after a night of drinking with friends, according to court documents.

McGeoghean didn't remember a thing, according to the Boston Globe, and woke up that morning to find her daughter unresponsive and blue strapped in a car seat on the living room floor.

A jury found the mother guilty and sentenced her to life in prison.

Pleading: Nancy McGeoghean has been in a state prison for more than 20 years for killing her two-year-old daughter and is now pleasing for her freedom

Pleading: Nancy McGeoghean has been in a state prison for more than 20 years for killing her two-year-old daughter and is now pleasing for her freedom

That was 26 years ago. And now, at 45-years-old, McGeoghean is pleading for her freedom.

Rare in the state, McGeoghean is being given a chance to persuade the Massachusetts Advisory Board of Pardons to recommend that she be eligible for release from the Framingham prison, something that hasn't been done in more than 15 years, according to the Globe.

In the Dec. 29 hearing, McGeoghean spoke about killing her daughter and not remembering committing the crime, even though she initially denied killing her daughter in the 1989 trial.

'I am ashamed of myself. I am disgusted with myself,' McGeoghean reportedly said in the hearing.

'I loved Sarah. She was the only thing in the whole world that was mine.'

McGeoghean earned the rare shot due to her behavior in prison, Board officials said. According to the Globe, McGeoghean trained service dogs and counseled other prisoners during the unusually long sentence.

The decision to recommend is now up to Governor Deval Patrick. If he agrees to the commutation of McGeoghean's sentence, her case will go to the Governor's Council for a vote, the Globe reports.

If the Council votes yes, McGeoghean will be eligible for parole.

Vote: The decision to recommend McGeoghean for commutation is now in the hands of  Governor Deval Patrick (photographed)

Vote: The decision to recommend McGeoghean for commutation is now in the hands of Governor Deval Patrick (photographed)

However, according to the state's website, a commutation is not forgiveness for the 'underlying offense.'

'It simply means that the period of incarceration served for the offense has been reduced.'

Born to abusive, alcoholic parents, McGeoghean had Sarah at 18 years old and was addicted to drugs and alcohol.

She and Sarah were living in a 'flea-infested' apartment in Cambridge at the time of the murder, according to Patch.

A psychiatrist who examined McGeoghean at the time said she was undergoing withdrawal after heavy use of cocaine and 'just snapped.'

However, court documents state that prosecutors said McGeoghean killed Sarah with 'deliberate premeditation and malice aforethought.'

Court documents also state that McGeoghean 'inflicted cigarette burns on Sarah's chest' in the months before her death.

Though initially McGeoghean said she didn't believe she was capable of killing her own daughter, she said in the hearing that there is 'no other explanation.'

'I believe I killed her,' McGeoghean said.

A board member asked McGeoghean at the hearing why she thinks she did it, according to the Globe. McGeoghean shook her head and cried.

'Not remembering is torture to me,' she replied.

Read more:

MOST WATCHED NEWS VIDEOS

MOST READ NEWS

 

 
 

Colorado News

Get the latest Colorado news, sports, weather, entertainment, business & political news and more from Colorado Newsday.
 
  • Email to a friend Email to a friend
  • Print version Print version
  • Plain text Plain text

Rate this article

0
 
 
 
 
  1. Drunk tractor driver decapitates three people in head-on crash (1.50)

  2. Spoiled’ teen takes parents to court (1.00)

  3. Terms of Service (0)

  4. Colorado Newsday Privacy Policy (0)

  5. The secret behind Amazon's low prices (0)

  6. Kim Kardashian denied access to Vanity Fair party (0)

  7. Russian troops threaten to shoot Ukrainian soldiers in tense stand-off (0)

  8. Boxer vows to fight on – after 51st defeat in row (0)

  9. Forbes rich list names world’s youngest billionaires (0)

  10. FriXion social network aims to link sex toys online so couples can play together (0)

  11. Margaret Cho accused of promoting racist stereotype as she lampoons Sony hack with North Korean general sketch at Golden Globes (0)

  12. A BRIEF encounter like no other: Subway riders in New York join thousands of commuters across the globe ditching their pants to celebrate the 'No Pants Subway Ride' (0)

  13. Eight-year-old boy dies after spending SIX YEARS in a vegetative state following horror crash with 'drunk driver' (0)

  14. The cannabis queens of Beverly Hills: Mother and daughter who have built business empire from medicinal marijuana (0)

  15. 'Rupert Murdoch is a pus sore': Adam Hills fires up with scathing tweet after media mogul said all Muslims should be held responsible for Paris terror attack  (0)

  16. Ethan Odom charged with 'kidnapping' girl through her bedroom window (0)

  17. One step closer to knowing why AirAsia jet crashed into the sea: Divers bring black box to the surface... and now hunt for cockpit voice recorder (0)

  18. Fight to save ailing Duke the mastiff following horrific reaction to vaccine just days after he heroically saved family's baby (0)

  19. Chinese wife chopped cheating husband's penis off... twice (0)

  20. Monica Lewinsky emerges at HBO Golden Globes after party arm-in-arm with best friend Alan Cumming (0)

  21. 'I couldn't be more proud to be called your husband:' George Clooney swoons for new wife Amal and jokes about Sony hacks in lifetime achievement acceptance speech (0)

  22. Anyone for dog meat soup? Kim Jong-Un considers opening restaurant in Scotland selling North Korean delicacies (0)

  23. NYPD work slowdown eases after threat to ban vacations and sick days... but Commissioner Bratton insists he is still 'concerned' by decreas in police activity  (0)

  24. 'Je suis Charlie': Helen Mirren uses the Golden Globes to show her support for the French people after terrorist attacks in Paris (0)

  25. 'Sleeping Beauty just thought she was getting coffee with Bill Cosby': Tina Fey and Amy Poehler ridicule embattled comic in first minutes of Golden Globes (0)

  26. GOP congressman invokes Hitler in tweet criticizing Obama for skipping Paris march (0)

  27. You'll scream for this ice cream: McDonald's customer finds 'souls of the damned' floating in fast food sundae (0)

  28. 'I just crumpled him': Pastor acts out moment he punched a kid in the chest and 'brought him to the Lord' (0)

  29. Lawyer of Texas cop filmed firing his TASER at 76-year-old says there was 'nothing unreasonable' about his actions (0)

  30. Two Tuskegee Airmen, 91, die on the same day: Veterans of famous all-black WWII flying squadron pass away 70 years after first combat mission (0)

  31. Fox News terror expert apologises after claiming Birmingham is 'totally Muslim' and 'non-Muslims just simply don't go in' (0)

  32. A new iPad accessory... cream to banish Tech Neck wrinkles: State-of-the-art treatment vows to tackle sagging skin caused by constantly looking down at tablet (0)

  33. Christian couple unwilling to destroy frozen embryos following IVF give them up for 'adoption' to other would-be parents facing fertility woes (0)

  34. Golden Globes winners are announced live at the Beverly Hilton Hotel in Los Angeles (0)

  35. Golden Globes night #AskHerMore Twitter trend pushes interviewers to pose more thoughtful questions on the red carpet (0)

  36. Boyhood sweeps the board while Julianne Moore and Eddie Redmayne take home top acting honors at the Golden Globes (0)

  37. Extraordinary half-male, half-female butterfly discovered at Philadelphia university (0)

  38. Father 'tried to use his fifth-month-old son as a HUMAN SHIELD in police shootout' (0)

  39. FBI reveals Imam who inspired Charlie Hebdo terrorists has been busted multiple times for soliciting prostitutes (0)

  40. French gunman's fugitive widow told police she and husband used to discuss Al Qaeda attacks and had the right 'to take up arms'  (0)

  41. Is this the Islamic State's youngest suicide bomber? Syrian boy who appears to only be around 14 shown detonating a lorry full of explosives (0)

  42. Oscar Mayer mansion in Evanston, Illinois is on the market for $1.75million (0)

  43. Montana family welcomes 'one in a million' set of identical triplets  (0)

  44. 2015 Golden Globes finds Jane Fonda's boyfriend passing out and Kathy Bates denying she collapsed (0)

  45. Jennifer Lopez, Reese Witherspoon, Kate Hudson and Emily Blunt sparkle in white as they walk the red carpet at the Golden Globes (0)

  46. North Carolina city removes display of soldier kneeling next to a cross after being sued by an Army veteran (0)

  47. Which diet is right for YOU? Take this quiz to determine if you're an emotional eater, a constant craver or a feaster - and learn how to keep the pounds off for good (0)

  48. Can a real woman pull off new extreme cleavage style? (0)

  49. World's first pay-by-POKER restaurant opens in London (0)

  50. US cartoonist still in hiding four years after encouraging fellow satirists to join an 'Everybody draw Mohammed day' (0)