Home | News | Regional | Monster CEO sues Beats co-founders Dr Dre and Jimmy Iovine for 'swindling him before $3billion sale to Apple'

Monster CEO sues Beats co-founders Dr Dre and Jimmy Iovine for 'swindling him before $3billion sale to Apple'

By
Font size: Decrease font Enlarge font
  • In lawsuit, Monster CEO Noel Lee targets Beats, Dr Dre and Jimmy Iovine
  • Says co-founders intentionally orchestrated 'sham' deal with HTC in 2011
  • This deal, he claims, led to termination of Monster alliance two years later
  • Mr Lee was 'assured that firm would not be sold for at least several years'
  • But last May, Beats was sold to Apple - he would have made $30m-$150m
  • California-based suit also targets HTC and Paul Wachter, Beats investor

By Sophie Jane Evans For Dailymail.com and Associated Press

Published: 00:40 EST, 7 January 2015 | Updated: 01:32 EST, 7 January 2015

View
comments

The CEO of technology firm Monster is suing Beats Electronics and its co-founders Dr Dre and Jimmy Iovine for allegedly duping him before selling the headphone company to Apple for $3billion.

In the complaint, filed in a California court on Tuesday, Noel Lee, who also founded the video and audio cable maker, accuses rapper Dr Dre and record producer Mr Iovine of double crossing him.

Mr Lee - who once held a 5 percent stake in Beats via a Monster-Beats partnership that ended in 2012 - claims the pair deliberately orchestrated a 'sham' deal with smartphone maker HTC in 2011.

This deal, he says, led to the termination of the Monster alliance - he pared his stake in Beats to 1.25 per cent before selling his remaining holdings for $5.5 million in the autumn of 2013.

Lawsuit: The CEO of technology firm Monster is suing Beats Electronics and its co-founders Dr Dre (left) and Jimmy Iovine (right) for allegedly duping him before selling the headphone company to Apple for $3billion
Lawsuit: The CEO of technology firm Monster is suing Beats Electronics and its co-founders Dr Dre (left) and Jimmy Iovine (right) for allegedly duping him before selling the headphone company to Apple for $3billion

Lawsuit: The CEO of technology firm Monster is suing Beats Electronics and its co-founders Dr Dre (left) and Jimmy Iovine (right) for allegedly duping him before selling the headphone company to Apple for $3billion

At the time, he was assured by Beats executives that there were no plans to sell the company for at least several years, he states in the lawsuit, which was filed in San Mateo Superior Court.

However, following Dr Dre's and Mr Iovine's alleged shady maneuvering, Beats announced its sale to Apple last May, enabling the pair to become executives at the iPhone and iPad maker.

Had he held on to his 1.25 percent stake, Mr Lee would have received more than $30 million in the Apple deal. His original 5 percent stake would have been worth roughly $150 million.

Both Dr Dre, whose real name is Andre Young, and Mr Iovine, a longtime recording industry executive, reaped the biggest jackpots in the Apple deal.

However, the precise size of their windfalls has not been disclosed. In his lawsuit, Mr Lee states the pair each owned 15 percent stakes in the early stages of the Beats partnership.

Besides Dr Dre and Mr Iovine, the lawsuit targets HTC America Holding Ltd. and Paul Wachter, a Beats investor and board member.

Monster CEO: In the complaint, filed in a California court on Tuesday, Noel Lee (pictured), who also founded the video and audio cable maker, accuses rapper Dr Dre and record producer Mr Iovine of double crossing him

Monster CEO: In the complaint, filed in a California court on Tuesday, Noel Lee (pictured), who also founded the video and audio cable maker, accuses rapper Dr Dre and record producer Mr Iovine of double crossing him

'Fraud': Mr Lee - who once held a 5 percent stake in Beats (file picture) via a Monster-Beats partnership that ended in 2012 - claims the pair deliberately orchestrated a 'sham' deal with smartphone maker HTC in 2011

'Fraud': Mr Lee - who once held a 5 percent stake in Beats (file picture) via a Monster-Beats partnership that ended in 2012 - claims the pair deliberately orchestrated a 'sham' deal with smartphone maker HTC in 2011

Apple Inc, which now employs Dre and Iovine, declined to comment on the lawsuit. The Cupertino company isn't named in the complaint.

Mr Lee's bitterness in his lawsuit seemingly contradicts how he described the culmination of the Monster-Beats partnership in a late 2013 interview with The Associated Press (AP).

At that time, Lee called it an 'amicable' parting and said he was paid 'very generously' in royalties.

This isn't the first time that a former Beats partner has lashed out at Dre and Iovine in court.

David Hyman, who sold his music streaming service MOG to Beats in 2012, is suing the pair for bad faith. That action, filed shortly before the Apple deal, is unfolding in Los Angeles Superior Court.

Executives: The HTC deal led to the termination of the Monster alliance. Last May, Beats announced its sale to Apple last May, enabling Dr Dre (right) and Mr Iovine (left) to become executives at the iPhone and iPad maker

Executives: The HTC deal led to the termination of the Monster alliance. Last May, Beats announced its sale to Apple last May, enabling Dr Dre (right) and Mr Iovine (left) to become executives at the iPhone and iPad maker

In Mr Lee's case, he appears to be interested in recovering the money that he believes he lost through the alleged misconduct of Dr Dre and Mr Iovine.

The lawsuit also depicts the executive as the brains behind the Beats By Dre headphones, while casting Dr Dre and Mr Iovine as little more than figureheads.

One section of the lawsuit likens Mr Lee to two more famous innovators, Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak and sound-system pioneer Ray Dolby.

Voicemails seeking comment were left for Dr Dre's attorney and Beats by AP on Tuesday.

MOST WATCHED NEWS VIDEOS

MOST READ NEWS

 

 
 

Colorado News

Get the latest Colorado news, sports, weather, entertainment, business & political news and more from Colorado Newsday.
 
  • Email to a friend Email to a friend
  • Print version Print version
  • Plain text Plain text

Rate this article

0
 
 
 
 
  1. Drunk tractor driver decapitates three people in head-on crash (1.50)

  2. Spoiled’ teen takes parents to court (1.00)

  3. Terms of Service (0)

  4. Colorado Newsday Privacy Policy (0)

  5. 'Diary of Virginia Roberts who claims she had sex with Prince Andrew reveals details'  (0)

  6. The secret behind Amazon's low prices (0)

  7. Jeremy Jackson was accused of attempted murder of his ex-wife (0)

  8. 'Doctors say I'm immune, but I don't plan to test that': Ebola survivor Dr. Rick Sacra soon to return to Liberia hot zone (0)

  9. Butter dish warms butter so it's soft enough to spread and keeps it cool in the summer (0)

  10. Falcon takes down glider after it flies too close to its nest (0)

  11. NYPD union meeting thrown into chaos as as cops shout down boss who demanded apology from de Blasio (0)

  12. Arrested teen helps save cop's life after officer collapses with a heart attack while trying to book him into jail  (0)

  13. Michael Wayne McIntosh who started underage prostitution ring at his house appears in court (0)

  14. Incredible moment man who was abducted as a four-year-old is reunited with his father 24 YEARS after he was snatched from a market in China (0)

  15. Jodi Arias secret testimony where she pleaded not be executed revealed (0)

  16. Silk Road founder Ross Ulbricht made $18m peddling illegal drugs online (0)

  17. Jamie Dornan on 'Fifty Shades' role: 'No actor could live up to that' (0)

  18. Emergency evacuation on the International Space Station after a leak 'harmful' of ammonia in U.S. section forces astronauts to flee to safety (0)

  19. Pregnant Heather Mack who 'murdered her mother and put body in a suitcase' arrives at trial in Bali  (0)

  20. Judge DENIES request to delay Boston bomber jury selection after defense lawyers claimed Paris terror attacks 'could taint jury pool' (0)

  21. EXCLUSIVE: Four hours before he died, footage from inside Paris deli shows jihadist herding terrified customers and forcing them to deactivate security cameras as corpses lay around them (0)

  22. Chris Pratt named Hasty Pudding's 2015 Man of the Year (0)

  23. Gigi Hadid named the new face of Maybelline (0)

  24. Disney to release 'Ghost in the Shell' in 2017 (0)

  25. Kristin Cavallari shares vacation photo with Jay Cutler (0)

  26. Demi Lovato, Wilmer Valderrama considering marriage (0)

  27. Jimmy Kimmel to guest host 'The Bachelor' (0)

  28. Kathy Griffin slams Amal Clooney on 'Fashion Police' (0)

  29. Preview Leonardo DiCaprio, Robert De Niro in Martin Scorsese short (0)

  30. Madonna, AC/DC, Ariana Grande to perform at the Grammys (0)

  31. Chris Kyle's widow reveals struggle watching American Sniper (0)

  32. 'Bradley Cooper is the real deal' says Navy SEAL who trained him (0)

  33. Leader of al-Qaeda's Yemen group confirms they ordered Charlie Hebdo attack (0)

  34. IRS warns that this year will bring slower tax refunds and more identity theft due to massive budget cuts - but far less audits (0)

  35. Cat named Sunny rescued after nearly losing her ears to frostbite on dangerously cold Chicago streets (0)

  36. 'I began to wake up': How a man spent 12 years trapped in comatose state brought on by mystery illness watching endless reruns of Barney until his mind 'switched on' (0)

  37. Yosemite climbers expect to reach top of El Capitan on Wednesday (0)

  38. Republican National Committeeman under fire for Facebook-sharing racist essay that claimed blacks 'are a threat to all who cross their paths' (0)

  39. Derek Hough to depart 'Dancing with the Stars' (0)

  40. Kate Gosselin says single life is 'definitely lonely' (0)

  41. Brian Williams weighs in on daughter Allison Williams' racy 'Girls' scene (0)

  42. Joe Mantegna and Drea de Matteo to help out on AMC docu-series about the mob (0)

  43. How oxygen in the air could trigger lung cancer: Rates of the disease found to decrease at higher altitudes (0)

  44. Apple Watch app revealed (0)

  45. Spared Charlie Hebdo journalist Sigolène Vinson reveals how she stared into killer's eyes (0)

  46. Hope Solo's domestic violence charges for fight dismissed (0)

  47. Charlie Hebdo sells out in shops across France within an hour of its latest edition featuring cover of a weeping Mohammed going on sale (0)

  48. Glenn Close's sister reveals tormented life of delusions, drugs and promiscuity (0)

  49. 10-month-old Columbian baby Juanita Valentina Hernandez who weighs as much as a five-year-old (0)

  50. Following the AirAsia tragedy, Airbus considers adding ejectable black boxes to commercial aircraft (0)